![]() |
| G. Amato |
Gaetano 'Tommy Scar' Amato was a soldier in the Genovese Family active in Brooklyn.
He had a long history of associating with Members and Associates of the Colombo Family.
Born October 29, 1913 in Brooklyn to Francesco Amato (42y) and Anna Cozzolino (26y). Father was born in Palermo and mother born in Naples, Italy.
At the time of birth the family resided at 160 Union St, in Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn.
By 1925 the family had moved to nearby 514 Henry St.
By 1930 the family had moved to 390 Clinton St, also in Carroll Gardens.
On December 21, 1936 arrested with two others on charges of having no visible means of support. The NYPD described the men as "degenerates" and arrested them after
their car sped down Broadway in Manhattan.
On April 4, 1940 picked up for vagrancy by the NYPD. Also arrested was Paul Ruggerio (29y) of 549 Henry St, said by police to be a recently released convict.
By October 1940 he was residing at 9 Prince St in Manhattan and gave his occupation as a longshoreman.
By 1950 he and wife resided at 38 President St in Brooklyn.
By 1958 formally inducted member of Genovese Family.
In an FBI report dated October 8, 1963 FBI CI and Colombo Family member Gregory Scarpa identified Amato as a Member of Cosa Nostra.
In October 1967 included in the FBI's list of identified Genovese Family members.
Attended a 1969 New Year's Eve party at a mob social club, along with Colombo Family Member Dominick Scialo. On October 5, 1971 an FBI CI advised: "[Informant] advised that on New Year's Eve 1969 at the West Side Civic Club on New Utrecht and 81st Streets, MIMI got extremely drunk and became very abusive toward two of CARLO GAMBINO's young associates, who promptly gave SCIALO a severe beating. They had guns and were going to kill SCIALO but were stopped by TOMMY "SCAR" AMATO.
[Informant] advised that SCIALO who is not Sicilian has an intense hatred for Sicilians and this becomes very evident when he drinks. [Informant] further advised that although SCIALO probably has some gambling operation going, it is not a big one and that he heard SCIALO is shaking down bar owners in the Coney Island area for fifty bucks a week."
In the early 1970s partner with Family Boss Joe Colombo (1923-1978) in a gambling operation in Bath Beach, Brooklyn. On April 7, 1971 Amato and Colombo were among 38 persons arrested for violation of Federal Gambling laws. Amato was arrested at 80-11 New Utrecht Avenue in Bensonhurst. At the time he was residing at 297 Bay 10th Street in Bath Beach.
The Amato/Colombo operation laid off its 'numbers action' to a numbers bank located at 218 Grand St in Manhattan. Probably the same numbers bank controlled by Genovese Members Thomas Eboli and Eli Zeccardi. The FBI arrest report stated:
"AMATO admitted his identity but refused to answer any questions concerning his alleged involvement in violation of Federal laws relating to an illegal gambling business of the FBI. AMATO was then transported to the New York Office"
In 1972 identified by the NYPD OC Squad as a customer of the Anthony Granata/Joseph 'Sam' Pontillo Cigarette smuggling operation. As Colombo Family Associates Granata and Pontillo headed NYC's largest smuggling ring but were financially backed by Genovese family Members Vincent and Mario Gigante.
![]() |
| A. Granata |
A December 15, 1973 report from the NYPD's Organized Crime Control Bureau stated: "[Anthony Granata] is the largest smuggler of untaxed cigarettes in the N.Y. area. His customers include members of Catena,Tramunti, Colombo & Gambino families such as, Gaetano Amato (Guy Russo), a soldier Genovese Family; Anthony DeLutro, soldier in Gambino Family and close associate of Aniello Dellacroce; Frank Malvagna, soldier in Colombo Family; Ralph Marino, alleged godson of Buster Aloi, Capo in Colombo Family; Anthony Pinto, soldier in Tramunti Family; and Anthony Castaldi, a soldier in Tramunti Family. He was last arrested on March 29, 1973, and charged with violation of the untaxed cigarettes statutes."
In early 1973 Granata and Pontillo ended their partnership and Pontillo started his own cigarette smuggling operation that was financially backed by Amato and Lucchese Family Members Anthony Pinto and Anthony 'Tony Bones' Castaldi.
On October 11, 1973 Amato, Pontillo and Carlo Noia were arrested as they were unloading 3600 cartons of cigarettes out of a truck in a Brooklyn parking lot. Amato, Noia and charged with possessing untaxed cigarettes. Pontillo was also charged with bribery after he offered a detective $5000.
Six months later Carlo Noia was indicted as part of Colombo Member Gregory Scarpa, Sr. crew attempting to sell stolen stocks. Among those also indicted together with Noia and Scarpa, Sr was Future Colombo Members Robert Zambardi and Joseph DeDomenico.
On August 14, 1974 Pontillo was shot two times in the stomach as he was standing on a street in Sheepshead bay, Brooklyn. Five months earlier a close associate of his, Anthony 'Tony Ninny' Giordano had been shot dead in Brooklyn.
He was identified as a Soldier in the 1983 Senate Chart.
On December 3, 1911 shot dead as he was standing in front of a social club at 2284 McDonald Ave. The intended victim was Colombo Family Associate Joseph Tolino (38y) who was aligned with the Orena faction. The shooters were part of the Gregory Scarpa Crew aligned with the rival Persico faction. On December 11, 1991 Gregory Scarpa reported to his FBI handler, Lindley DeVecchio:
"[Scarpa] said the hit on GAETANO AMATO was an accidental shooting by the PERSICO faction when attempting to hit TOLINO. The PERSICO faction contacted the GENOVESE Family and expressed their apologies for the shooting, and were told by tals of the GENOVESE Family that it was regrettable about it, but he should have known better than to be in a COLOMBO location and there would be no retaliation. The [Scarpa] said the believed Persico side them to be members close to NICHOLAS Grancio at that location prior to the shooting."
DeVecchio wrote about the murder in his 2011 book "We're going to win this thing: The shocking frame-up of a Mafia crime buster":
"December 3, 1991: The Persico faction struck back and had their first kill. It was not exactly a trophy kill. The victim was seventy-eight-year-old Gaetano Amato. He was a Genovese made man who was then "on the shelf," that is, semiretired. Gaetano made the error in judgment of hanging out in front of a social club belonging to my civil lawsuit murder victim Nicky Black Grancio. Drive-by shooters under Greg Scarpa were looking for Nicky Black and were aiming for another Colombo button when they shot and killed Gaetano by mistake. Since the old guy was no longer a Genovese Family moneymaker, his Boss, Chin Gigante, took the hit in stride. Chin generously blamed Gaetano for getting himself killed and paid for the funeral."










